IBM
基本信息
International Business Machines Corporation,美国老牌信息技术与服务公司。Druckenmiller 把 IBM 当作”管理层为了取悦短期股东而牺牲长期竞争力”的反面教材,反复用它对照 Amazon。
德鲁肯米勒的核心观点
用回购而非投资——长期会被吃掉
2015 年 11 月:IBM 自 2006 年以来 14 个季度收入下滑、R&D 占销售从 6.2% 降至 5.9%(且基数萎缩),却面对 Amazon、Palantir 等公司的全方位侵蚀。“在这种状态下你 R&D 还在缩——这算什么转型?“
$189 高位回购的”股东回报”
“他们以平均 189 美元的价格回购了 430 亿美元股票。他们说自己是资本的好管家、向股东返还价值——但股票现在 142 美元。这不是我心中的’股东回报’。” 他对此明确拒绝把”转型期”作为辩解。
2017 年仍是反面例子
2017 年 12 月:他不再具体说 IBM 是不是当时的好做空,但仍把它列为”投资不足、回购、分红,眼睁睁让对手在云和 AI 领域吃掉自己午餐”的典型公司。
与 Ginni Rometty 的隔空交锋
当 IBM 时任 CEO Ginni Rometty 称公司处于”转型期”需要时间,Druckenmiller 当场拒绝:“不,我不相信这个转型。“
原文引用
CNBC Interview - Stan Druckenmiller on Fed Policy (2015-11-04)
“IBM has missed three quarters since 2006 — they really care about their quarterly earnings. … Their R&D has shrunk as a percentage of sales. They’re under major attack from Amazon, Palantir, and all these companies out there eating away at them. … They bought back $43 billion in stock at an average price of $189. They say they’re stewards of capital and returning value to shareholders — but I don’t know how you buy something at $189 when it’s at $142. That’s not my kind of return to shareholders.”
来源:CNBC Interview - Stan Druckenmiller on Fed Policy
Legendary Investor Stanley Druckenmiller On The Stock Market, Tax Reform, And His Stock Picks - CNBC (2017-12-14)
“I don’t know whether IBM stock is a short right now — but that’s the kind of company which, to me, has been under-investing, buying back stock, paying dividends, while competitors are basically eating their lunch in cloud and AI and everything else that competitiveness is built on.”
来源:Legendary Investor Stanley Druckenmiller On The Stock Market, Tax Reform, And His Stock Picks - CNBC